Mimi’s Ice Box Lemon Pie

“In the South, I think, food mirrors our lives. When I was growing up, no matter what you were grieving or celebrating, my mama would be at the door with a cake or a pie.” –  Kimberly Schlapman

Before I go too much further I am going to post my mother’s Ice Box Lemon Pie. Many people (well, some people) have asked for this recipe and I am happy to oblige.

Ice Box Lemon Pie is a staple in the south, especially in the hotter months. You can, of course, purchase a lemon meringue pie at any grocery store and most fast food chains, but once you’ve tasted this version, made from scratch, all store bought versions will pale in comparison. It is commonly kept refrigerated and is served cold as a refreshing ending to any meal. It was commonly referred to as “lemon icebox pie” because you chilled it in the ice box and the name stuck.

In the days before electricity was commonly available, most people had an ice box. My grandmother called her refrigerator an “ice box” throughout her life. Wooden ice boxes were predecessors of refrigerators. The earliest versions date back to around 1830. Made from hardwood such as oak or walnut, ice boxes looked similar to a large dresser. Hollow walls were lined with zinc or tin and packed with insulating materials such as flax straw fiber, sawdust, seaweed, cork, mineral wool or charcoal. There were several storage compartments inside, including the ice compartment, which had a drainage hole. Melted ice water was collected in a catch pan or holding tank that would need to be emptied on a daily basis. An iceman delivered ice to patrons in his horse and buggy every morning.

Similar to key lime pie, this dessert shares common ingredients with its cousin. If you’re tempted to skimp on the fresh-squeezed juice and use store bought instead, don’t.

Meyer Lemons are best.

Freshness counts big with the flavor of this pie. There is nothing original about this recipe so I can’t claim creative rights. It came directly from my mother, but I’m sure every mother and grandmother in the south have a similar recipe. My children called my mother Mimi, hence the name I am using for the pie.

Here is the actual recipe card that my mother passed on to Karel, probably in the early 1970’s. You can see it has been well used.


Graham Cracker Crust Recipe

Form graham cracker crust in pie pan

1/2 Cup fresh lemon juice

Add juice to milk – egg mixture and “beat real well”

We use vanilla extract.

Pour lemon filling into cooked graham cracker crust.

Whip egg whites with sugar and gently spread over pie filling. Top with a light sprinkle of turbinado sugar and bake for about 8-10 minutes at 375° or until the peaks are lightly browned.

The finished pie is fairly amazing!


6 thoughts on “Mimi’s Ice Box Lemon Pie

  1. Love this pie, Karel and Walter! Thanks for posting the recipe. We had an ice box for awhile. I remember putting the sign in the widow for the number of pounds of ice we needed, the ice man’s tongs, and what happened if you forgot to empty the pan. Mary

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s